메뉴
HN
Hacker News 33일 전

윈도우 11 강제 설정 팝업, IT 생산성 저하

IMP
7/10
핵심 요약

윈도우 11 업데이트 후 사용자에게 불쑥 나타나는 '초기 설정 완료(SCOOBE)' 화면이 마이크로소프트의 구독 서비스 광고를 강요하고 있습니다. 이는 개인 사용자의 불편함을 넘어 기업 환경에서 업무 흐름을 끊고 IT 인프라 관리 부담을 가중시키는 심각한 문제로 지적되고 있습니다.

번역된 본문

노트북을 사용한 지 몇 달이 지났고, 항상 마이크로소프트 업데이트를 설치했다고 가정해 봅시다. 어느 날 부팅을 하면 윈도우 11이 혼란스러운 메시지와 함께 당신을 맞이합니다. "PC 설정이 거의 끝났습니다." 거의 끝났다고요? 이게 무슨 의미일까요? 당신은 윈도우 11에서 컴퓨터 설정을 아주 오래전에 마쳤는데, 여기서는 설치가 실제로 완료되지 않았다고 말하고 있습니다. 앞으로 무슨 완료된 일을 아직 끝내지 않았다는 말을 듣게 될까요? 혹시 5년 전에 결혼 증명서에 서명하는 것을 잊었나요? 10년 전 내 집 계약서에 이니셜을 적는 것을 놓쳤나요? 아니면 2003년에 본 운전면허 시험에서 중요한 코너를 놓쳤나요? 당신의 아이 출생증명서에 부모로 이름이 올라가 있는지 확실한가요?

그래서 대화 상자 하단에 나타난 '계속' 버튼을 클릭하면, 윈도우는 마이크로소프트에서 권장하는 브라우저 설정을 사용할지 묻습니다. 설정이 무엇인지 확실하지 않지만, '권장 설정 사용' 버튼을 누르게 됩니다. 그럴듯하게 들어고 '권장 설정 사용 안 함' 버튼이 없기 때문입니다. (화면 다른 곳에 토글 스위치가 있지만 이것도 헷갈립니다.) 이것이 어떤 영향을 미치는지는 명확하지 않습니다. 최근 테스트에서는 기본 브라우저를 구글 크롬에서 마이크로소프트 엣지로 변경하지는 않았지만, 사용자마다 결과가 다를 수 있습니다.

다음으로, 휴대폰을 PC에 연결하여 데스크톱에서 SMS 메시지를 받을 수 있도록 권장하는 화면이 나옵니다. 얼핏 괜찮아 보이지만, 지금 당장 이 작업을 원하지 않기 때문에 '다음' 버튼(예에 해당) 대신 '건너뛰기' 링크를 보고 클릭하게 됩니다.

그런 다음 Office가 설치되어 있음을 상기시키고 '알겠습니다' 버튼을 클릭하도록 만드는 또 다른 화면이 나타납니다. 이쯤 되면 마이크로소프트가 정형외과 의사들과 공모하여 사용자가 수근관 증후군에 걸릴 때까지 클릭을 유도하려는 것인지 의심하기 시작합니다. 하지만 MS Office가 없었다면, 바로 이 지점에서 마이크로소프트가 구독을 팔려고 했을 것입니다.

마침내, 다음 화면은 마이크로소프트가 왜 사용자가 이 전체 설정 과정을 겪게 만드는지 정확한 이유를 보여줍니다. 바로 Xbox Game Pass 프리미엄(미국 기준 월 14.99달러) 광고입니다. '나는 오래전에 Xbox Game Pass에 가입하지 않기로 결정했는데'라고 생각할 것입니다. 게다가 '이건 회사 PC인데' 말이죠.

여기서도 화면에 '$14.99에 가입' 버튼이 훨씬 눈에 띄지만, '건너뛰기' 링크를 클릭할 수는 있습니다. 운이 좋다면 이 후에 화면이 하나 더 나오는데, 브라우저에서 열리는 불필요한 윈도우 팁을 보여주며 '예'를 누르도록 유도합니다.

방금 경험한 것이 윈도우 11의 '두 번째 기회 초기 설정 경험(SCOOBE, Second Chance Out of Box Experience)'입니다. 이는 사용자가 더 많은 월간 서비스를 구매하거나 마이크로소프트가 원하는 설정을 사용하도록 속이려는 레드몬드의 매우 기만적이고 비윤리적인 시도입니다. SCOOBE는 PC를 처음 설정한 지 몇 달 또는 몇 년이 지난 후에도 실행될 수 있으며, PC 수명 주기 동안 여러 번 나타날 수 있습니다(주로 윈도우 업데이트 후). 이는 서비스 품질 저하의 사전적 정의이자, 작업이나 놀이를 준비하는 순간(부팅 시)에 마이크로소프트에 더 많은 돈을 지불하도록 조작하는 노골적인 시도입니다. 하지만 SCOOBE는 단순한 성가심이나 돈 뜯기 이상입니다. 이는 심각한 문제입니다.

원문 보기
원문 보기 (영어)
OSes 40 Go straight to sell! Windows second-chance setup hawks Microsoft services at IT's expense 40 The OS trying to upsell you subscriptions is more than just an annoyance Avram Piltch Sun 26 Apr 2026 // 11:38 UTC opinion You’ve had your laptop for months, and you’ve always made sure it installed Microsoft updates. Then one day you boot up, and Windows 11 greets you with a confusing message: “You’re almost done setting up your PC.” Almost done? What could that possibly mean? You set up your computer on Windows 11 a long time ago, but here it is telling you that your installation never actually finished. What other completed task will you next learn you haven’t actually finished? Did you perhaps forget to sign your marriage license five years ago, initial the deed to your home of 10 years, or miss a critical turn in the driving test you took back in 2003? Are you sure you’re named as the parent on your child’s birth certificate? You're almost done setting up your PC screen - Click to enlarge So you click the Continue button that appears at the bottom of the dialog box and Windows asks you if you’d like to use Microsoft’s recommended browser settings. You’re not sure what the settings are, but you hit the Use recommended settings button, because it all sounds above board and there’s no “Don’t use recommended settings” button (there’s a toggle in another part of the screen but that’s confusing). It's not clear what effect this has - in our recent test, it did not change the default browser from Google Chrome to Microsoft Edge, but your mileage may vary. Screen asks you to use recommended browser settings - Click to enlarge Next, you’re presented with a screen that encourages you to link your phone with your PC so you can get SMS messages on your desktop. This seems innocent enough, but you see and hit the Skip link (as opposed to the Next button which is yes) because you don’t want to do this right now. Screen asks you to set up phone connection to your PC - Click to enlarge You’re then hit with another screen that reminds you that you have Office installed and makes you click another button that says “Got it.” Now, you start to wonder if Microsoft is in league with the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons and is just trying to make you click until you get carpal tunnel syndrome. But if you didn’t have MS Office, this might be the place where Microsoft tries to sell you a subscription. This screen would try to sell you Office 365 if you didn't already have it installed - Click to enlarge Finally, the next screen shows you exactly why Microsoft is making you go through this entire setup process. It’s an advertisement for Xbox Game Pass Premium, which now costs $14.99 a month (if you’re in the US). “But I chose not to sign up for Xbox Game Pass a long time ago,” you think. “Also, this is my corporate PC.” Screen attempts to sell you a subscription to Xbox Game Pass - Click to enlarge Again, you’re free to hit the Skip link, even though the "Join for $14.99" button is much more prominent on the screen. If you’re lucky, there’s only one more screen after this one and it offers you the chance to see some unnecessary Windows tips, which it will launch in your browser if you click Yes. Really unnecessary screen asks you if you'd like some Windows tips - Click to enlarge What you’ve just experienced is Windows 11’s Second Chance Out of Box Experience (SCOOBE), a deeply deceptive and unethical attempt on Microsoft’s part to con you into buying more monthly services or using settings that Redmond wants you to have. SCOOBE can launch months or even years after you’ve first set up your PC and you can get it multiple times in your PC’s lifecycle, often after a Windows update. It’s the dictionary definition of enshittification, a naked attempt to cajole you into giving Microsoft more money at a moment – boot up – when you’re getting ready to work or play. But SCOOBE is more than just an annoyance and a money-grab. It’s a serious problem for organizations with managed PCs. The weird setup pattern costs more than just a minute of employee productivity. It leads to support calls, because less-tech-savvy employees think that there’s something genuinely wrong with their work computers. In communicating with dozens of IT people, I heard numerous stories about support tickets and lost time due to the SCOOBE experience. If you haven’t heard of SCOOBE, it makes sense to call IT when your long-running computer suddenly says that it needs to complete setup. If I got it and didn’t know better, I would think that someone had just wiped my computer and reinstalled Windows. And I’d want IT to step in and get all my data back. “SCOOBE first appeared on our devices months after their configuration. The appearance timing was especially inconvenient since they appeared on our contributors' screens who were working actively on data collection and thought that there might be a technical issue with their machines,” Hanna Parkhots, data collection project manager at Unidata , an AI training data company, told The Register . “It led to numerous support ticket increases, which we found out by reviewing three error tickets filed within a week for the same SCOOBE-related message.” Even worse, employees may be tricked into buying or installing something that the IT department doesn’t want them to have. Users may intentionally or accidentally end up with an Xbox Game Pass or Microsoft Office subscription, along with the associated software. The organization may have its own preferred browser settings that Microsoft fools the user into overriding. A number of IT people I communicated with also cited the very negative effects of SCOOBE distractions on clients, patients, or others needing to receive immediate service from a provider. “The most frustrating instance was on our front-desk PC mid-consultation with a wedding client,” said Tatiana Egorova, a florist with Flowers N Baskets , who does her own IT support. “The screen hijacked itself, pushing Office subscriptions while we were trying to pull up venue photos. Not a great look.” Perhaps worst of all, SCOOBE breaks user trust by using a UI to try to trick users into doing something that Microsoft wants but businesses do not. “What makes SCOOBE especially frustrating to me is that it breaks trust in the device itself,” Athena Kavis, a web designer, told us. “It feels less like setup and more like an ad layer, and for small teams that already juggle enough, even one extra interruption can derail a task like fulfilling orders, updating branding assets, or responding to leads.” In the end, Microsoft is putting a boost in its subscription profits for services such as Office 365 and Xbox Game Pass over its obligation to help businesses that have already paid for Windows licenses. It’s not enough that you paid once when you bought a laptop with Windows 11 on it. The company wants your users to pay again, perhaps for something that has no place on a work PC (Xbox) or something your organization would decide to license at the IT level (Office). And what if the company has chosen to go with Google Workspace and Office is forbidden? “Enterprises tolerate SCOOBE because switching operating systems is expensive and inconvenient, but smaller organizations are affected more severely since each minute counts,” said Sheraz Ali, founder of the HARO Links Builder , a marketing agency. “Imagine if Apple did something similar and forced users to subscribe to the iCloud and App Store via a macOS update? They'd probably face a congressional hearing about it.” Windows Update is a torture chamber for seldom-used PCs Make Windows 11 more useful and less annoying with these 11 Registry hacks Microsoft keeps adding stuff into Windows we don't want – here's what we actually need If you're forced to use Windows 11, here's how to steal some of your time back How to disable SCOOBE If you’re an individual user, you can disable SCOOBE by navigating to Settings->System->